Mortgage rates jumped again this week.
The average 30-year fixed rate hit 7.28% on October 1, according to Freddie Mac. That is up from 7.03% the week before and 6.34% a year ago.
Usually this is where the internet tells everyone the housing market is about to collapse, nobody should buy anything, and we should all meet back here when rates hit 4%.
There is one small problem with that theory.
Chicago apparently did not get the memo.
Chicago is doing its own thing
September data from Realtor.com showed active listings in Chicago down 5.3% from a year earlier. Nationally, active inventory was up 5.4%.
New listings in Chicago were down 7.8%. Median list prices were up 4.6%. Homes were spending a median of 36 days on the market, compared with 61 days nationally.
None of that means every house is flying off the shelf. It definitely does not mean every seller can throw a ridiculous number on a listing and wait for someone to show up with a wheelbarrow full of money.
It does mean the national housing headline and the Chicago housing market are not always the same story.
The waiting game
I understand why people want to wait for rates to come down. A lower rate can materially change a monthly payment. That matters.
What gets overlooked is what happens if a lot of other buyers are waiting for the exact same thing.
If rates eventually fall and demand comes back faster than inventory, the house that looks expensive today may simply have more people trying to buy it tomorrow.
That is not a prediction. Rates could stay high. Prices could soften in certain segments. Economic conditions can change quickly.
It is just the part of the conversation I think gets lost when the entire housing market gets reduced to one number.
There is also no such thing as "the Chicago market"
A condo in Lakeview, a single-family home in Lincoln Park, a three-flat in Logan Square and a luxury rental downtown can behave completely differently at the same time.
That is what makes this stuff interesting to me.
The more useful question is not, "Is this a good time to buy real estate?"
It is, "What am I buying, where am I buying it, what does the competition look like, and does the math make sense for me?"
Not quite as catchy for a YouTube thumbnail, but probably more useful.
One number I would actually pay attention to
Freddie Mac's 7.28% rate is a national average, not the rate every borrower gets. Realtor.com recently highlighted research showing meaningful differences between lenders and borrower profiles.
So if I were seriously considering buying, I would spend less time refreshing the national mortgage-rate headline and more time figuring out the actual financing available to me.
Then I would look at the specific little corner of Chicago I care about.
Because right now, Chicago is being Chicago.
And that seems considerably more useful than pretending one national headline explains everything.
What I was reading
Chicago real estate broker with Rowland Group | Compass. I write about real estate, investing, Chicago, business and whatever rabbit hole I went down that week.
More Ryan's Take